Independent MP Rumeen Farhana of the Brahmanbaria-2 constituency has highlighted contradictions in statements by government ministers and advisers regarding the return of former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, along with issues related to her passport and national identity card (NID).
Speaking in the 13th National Parliament on Sunday (15 November) during a point of order on a notice under Rule 71, Farhana highlighted conflicting positions from different levels of the government. She noted that one adviser has said there should be no obstruction to Hasina’s return, while the State Minister for Foreign Affairs has stated that she will not be issued a passport or travel pass. Meanwhile, the Home Minister has said that applications for a passport and NID have not yet been verified.
Farhana also raised the issue of lifting any existing ban on Hasina’s passport amid these contradictory remarks.
She argued that, much like the famous Bengali literary line “Kadambari proved by dying that she had not died,” Sheikh Hasina continues to make her presence felt through various channels despite not being in the country. Farhana cited recent incidents in Gopalganj as the latest example.
According to Farhana, recent statements by ministers, state ministers, and advisers on Hasina’s return show no consistency.
She referred to remarks made on 9 November by Dr. Jahed Ur Rahman, the Prime Minister’s Adviser on Information and Broadcasting. Rahman said that whether Hasina returns on her own or is brought back, the government’s position is the same: it does not want to prevent her return. He added that even if sentenced to death, Hasina remains a Bangladeshi citizen. Farhana herself called for the withdrawal of any ban on Hasina’s passport.
In contrast, State Minister for Foreign Affairs Humayun Kabir stated on the same day that Hasina would not be given any passport or travel pass. He said Bangladesh would not issue a passport to any terrorist and that there was no plan to issue a new passport or NID. Other statements have also mentioned the possibility of bringing her back under a prisoner exchange agreement.
Referring to the Home Minister’s comments from 9 November, Farhana said the minister had indicated that the authenticity of the passport and NID applications had not yet been verified. The legal basis of the applications would be examined, after which the Foreign or Law Ministry would take further steps. The Home Minister also mentioned sending a letter to India through the Foreign Ministry under the existing repatriation agreement.
Law Minister Mohammad Asaduzzaman, speaking on 8 and 14 November, said the government was proceeding through legal channels. He stated that the government had completed all legal processes for bringing Hasina back and that the remaining decision now rested with India. He also remarked that there was no opportunity for Hasina to appeal the death sentence.
Farhana summarized the inconsistencies as follows: the adviser supports lifting the passport restriction, the State Minister for Foreign Affairs has directly ruled out issuing a passport, the Home Minister says the application has not been verified, and on the same day the State Minister for Foreign Affairs dismissed the application as ridiculous.
While highlighting the lack of coordination among these statements, Farhana’s microphone was switched off after her allotted two minutes expired.
