Preloader

Three months after the murders of retired Hindu teacher Ganpati Chakraborty and three family members in Mashuapara, Rangpur city, the Metropolitan Detective Police (DB) ran into trouble while trying to submit the charge sheet in court.

Multiple inconsistencies were found in the charge sheet, and the claim that the murders occurred in connection with a theft was leaked. As a result, the investigating officer took the documents back for correction.

On Sunday morning (22 November), Inspector Zinnat Ali of Rangpur Metropolitan DB brought the charge sheet to the Rangpur Metropolitan Sessions Judge Court. During verification of the papers in the relevant section of the court, several inconsistencies—including those related to the CID forensic report—were detected. The investigating officer then withdrew the charge sheet without submitting it. The incident has raised fresh questions about the investigation into the quadruple murder.

Public Prosecutor (PP) of the Rangpur Metropolitan Sessions Judge Court, Abdul Hadi Belal, told Bangla Tribune: “The charge sheet had defects, so it was asked to be corrected. It would not be appropriate to comment in detail on this matter.”

However, court sources said the charge sheet was prepared mainly on the basis of the confessional statements of the two arrested accused, Siddhartha Das and Mugdha Das, without a thorough investigation. The CID forensic lab report—which found Mugdha Das’s DNA on date seeds, Siddhartha Das’s DNA on pieces of cucumber, and the DNA of both on the ends of beedis—was not attached to the charge sheet. DNA of only Mugdha Das was also found on the gamchha (towel) wrapped around the neck of the deceased Pritilata Chakraborty.

From the beginning, relatives of the deceased, crime experts, and human rights activists had expressed suspicion that more people might have been involved in the murders. These allegations were not given proper importance during the investigation. The charge sheet was also not prepared in complete form.

How the Charge Sheet Was Withdrawn

In the morning, the media cell of Rangpur Metropolitan Police (RMP) informed journalists that the charge sheet in the case of the murders of teacher Ganpati Chakraborty and three family members would be submitted in court. Upon receiving the information, this reporter and journalists from various media outlets went to the Rangpur Metropolitan Magistrate Court.

There, investigating officer Zinnat Ali was seen arriving at the court premises with the case CD, charge sheet, and other documents. He then went to the Metropolitan Sessions Judge Court and attempted to submit the charge sheet in the relevant section.

At that time, a lawyer of the court, on condition of anonymity, told Bangla Tribune that while reviewing the charge sheet, several inconsistencies—including those related to the CID forensic report—were noticed. The lawyer advised the investigating officer to correct them. After that, Zinnat Ali quickly left the court premises with all the documents and informed senior officers at the Metropolitan Police office.

When contacted, Rangpur Metropolitan Police Commissioner Mahbubur Rashid and Additional Deputy Police Commissioner of Metropolitan DB Sanatan Chakraborty declined to comment. Sanatan Chakraborty, however, said journalists would be formally informed within a few days about the submission of the charge sheet.

Sources in the Metropolitan DB said investigating officer Inspector Zinnat Ali is due to retire soon. For this reason, he tried to hurriedly complete the investigation and prepare the charge sheet. In the charge sheet, the two accused—Mugdha Das and Siddhartha Das—were held responsible for killing the four people by strangulation. Due to the inconsistencies found in the investigation, it ultimately could not be submitted to the court.

DNA of the Accused on Date Seeds, Cucumber and Gamchha

On 12 October, the investigating officer stated that DNA of the two arrested accused, Siddhartha Das and Mugdha Das, had been found on several pieces of evidence in the murders of teacher Ganpati Chakraborty and three family members. Mugdha Das’s DNA was found on date seeds, Siddhartha Das’s on cucumber pieces, and DNA of both on beedi ends. Additionally, only Mugdha Das’s DNA was identified on the gamchha wrapped around the neck of the deceased Pritilata Chakraborty. Various samples collected from the crime scene were tested at the CID forensic laboratory in Dhaka, and these findings were mentioned in the DNA test reports.

At that time, investigating officer Zinnat Ali said that analysis of the DNA test reports, recovered evidence, confessional statements of the accused, and statements of witnesses proved the involvement of Siddhartha and Mugdha in the four murders. No DNA of anyone else except the four deceased and the two accused was found at the scene. He added that the investigation of the case had been completed and a charge sheet against the two accused would be submitted in court within the next month.

Zinnat Ali further said that the DNA test report was received from the CID office in Dhaka on 9 October. Earlier, 31 types of samples collected from the crime scene on 31 August and 1 September had been sent to the CID forensic laboratory for testing. Notable among these samples were date seeds, parts of cucumber, a fruit-cutting knife, foil used for taking yaba, cigarette ends, basin stains, and blood samples of the two accused.

No Evidence of Rape Found

After the four murders, there were suspicions and questions about whether the daughter of the deceased Ganpati Chakraborty, Agami Chakraborty, and her mother Pritilata Chakraborty had been raped. To confirm this, vaginal swab samples of the mother and daughter were also sent to the CID forensic laboratory for DNA testing. The investigating officer said the report found no evidence of rape.

How the Four Were Killed

Analysing the DNA test reports, recovered evidence, confessional statements of the accused given in court, testimony of four people in court, and statements of 56 people given to the police, the investigating officer described the roles in the murders.

According to Zinnat Ali, Ganpati Chakraborty was killed jointly by Siddhartha and Mugdha. His wife Pritilata Chakraborty was killed by Mugdha Das. Their college-going daughter Agami Chakraborty was killed by Siddhartha Das. And their 12-year-old son Ayush Chakraborty was killed jointly by Siddhartha and Mugdha.

Motive Was Theft of Money and Gold Ornaments

Regarding the reason for the four murders, Zinnat Ali had said on 12 October that the accused had received information that Ganpati Chakraborty had withdrawn 50–60 lakh taka from the bank after retirement and kept it at home. They also believed there were many gold ornaments in the house. With the intention of theft, they entered the house through the roof and then killed the family members one by one.

Zinnat Ali also said that local residents Shanto Das, Simanto Das, Dulal Sharma, and Bidut Das (caretaker of the Central Crematorium) gave testimony in court in the case. In addition, 56 people gave statements to the police.

On the night of 22 August, the bodies of retired teacher of Rangpur Zilla School Ganpati Chakraborty, his wife Pritilata Chakraborty, and their two children were recovered from their home in Mashuapara, Rangpur city. In connection with the incident, on 23 August, the elder brother of the deceased Ganpati Chakraborty, Gopinath Chakraborty, filed a murder case against unidentified accused at Kotwali Police Station of Rangpur city.

Police arrested Ganpati Chakraborty’s neighbours Siddhartha Das and Mugdha Das and sent them to Rangpur jail through the court. Later, they confessed to the murders in court. The case was initially investigated by Kotwali Police Station of the city, but the investigation responsibility was later handed over to the DB Police.

Get Voice of Bangladesh in your inbox

Sign up to receive awesome content in your inbox, every month.